Delayed Respawnse
  • About
  • Articles
  • Games
  • Franchises
  • Respawnses
  • Tier Lists
Find Your Next Game
  • Home
  • About
  • Articles
  • Games
  • Xbox
  • Playstation
  • Nintendo
  • PC
  • Franchises
  • Respawnses
  • How We Score Games
  • Tier Lists
  • Take Our Quiz
  • Join the Community
  1. /
  2. Tier Lists
  3. /
  4. Every Assassin’s Creed Protagonist Ranked

Every Assassin’s Creed Protagonist Ranked

Assassin’s Creed has introduced some of the most memorable heroes in modern gaming. From Ezio’s charismatic rise to Bayek’s emotional journey to modern standouts like Kassandra, Eivor, and Basim, each protagonist has shaped the identity of the franchise in a unique way. This guide ranks every major Assassin’s Creed protagonist, including Mirage and Shadows, to see who stands at the top and who falls short.

How the Protagonists Define Assassin’s Creed

Assassin’s Creed has one of the most diverse lineups of protagonists in modern gaming. Some are iconic and unforgettable. Some are quietly brilliant. Others are carried by their games rather than driving them. With the release of Mirage and Shadows, the roster has expanded once again, adding new faces to the long history of Assassins and their enemies.

This list ranks every major Assassin’s Creed protagonist based on character depth, personality, narrative impact, performance, and long term franchise legacy.

S
Ezio
Bayek
Kassandra
A
Connor Kenway
Edward Kenway
Eivor Varinsdottir
Altaïr Ibn La’Ahad
Basim Ibn Ishaq
B
Shay Patrick Cormac
Arno Dorian
Aveline de Grandpré
Naoe
Yasuke
C
Jacob Frye
Evie Frye
Alexios
Lydia Frye
D
Shao Jun
Arbaaz Mir
Nikolai Orelov
S Tier

Ezio Auditore da Firenze (AC II, Brotherhood, Revelations)

Ezio remains the definitive Assassin’s Creed protagonist because he delivers the most complete character arc in the series. Players watch him grow from a reckless teenager into a seasoned mentor who understands both the cost and the purpose of the Assassin life. His charm, emotional depth, and personal losses shape every game he leads, and his story is told with more care and development than almost any character in the franchise. Ezio carries the golden age of Assassin’s Creed, and his legacy continues to define what a great AC hero looks like.


Bayek of Siwa (Origins)

Bayek is powerful, compassionate, and emotionally grounded, which makes him the heart and soul of Origins. His story of loss and justice feels authentic, and his relationships with the people he helps make him one of the most human characters in the series. Bayek’s quiet strength and moral clarity shape the foundation of the Hidden Ones, and his presence elevates the game’s narrative far beyond its gameplay systems. He feels like a real person navigating a world full of political and personal conflicts, and that sincerity earns him a place among the franchise’s best.


Kassandra (Odyssey)

Kassandra brings unmatched charisma and confidence to Odyssey. Her humor, physical presence, and emotional range make her feel larger than life in the best possible way. She commands the screen in almost every interaction, turning even simple dialogue into memorable moments. Kassandra carries Odyssey’s enormous world with ease, giving the story a clear identity through her personality and choices. Her performance is so strong that she became the canonical protagonist, and she stands as one of the most impactful heroes of the modern Assassin’s Creed era.

A Tier

Connor Kenway (AC III)

Connor is often misunderstood, but over time his character has aged into one of the more mature and grounded protagonists in the series. He is reserved but principled, shaped by a life of conflict between cultures and ideologies. His journey is tragic, full of personal cost, and his unwavering sense of justice makes him compelling even when the world around him fails him. Connor’s quiet intensity and moral strength give AC III a more serious tone that stands out today as one of the franchise’s most sincere stories.


Edward Kenway (Black Flag)

Edward is charismatic and flawed in equal measure, which makes his growth feel real and earned. He begins as a selfish pirate chasing wealth and recognition, but over time he learns the value of loyalty, purpose, and sacrifice. His transformation from opportunistic rogue to dedicated assassin is one of the most satisfying arcs in the franchise. Edward’s energy, humor, and emotional depth make Black Flag unforgettable, and his personal story enhances the wider Assassin lore in surprising ways.


Eivor Varinsdottir (Valhalla)

Eivor is calm, confident, and deeply tied to the Viking culture that shapes their worldview. Their story feels grounded and personal, filled with relationships, alliances, and internal conflicts that define their role as both warrior and leader. Eivor carries a very long game with remarkable consistency, staying compelling through exploration, raids, mythology, and political intrigue. The only limitation is that Valhalla’s massive scope stretches their arc more than necessary, but the strength of the character still shines through.


Altaïr Ibn La’Ahad (AC I, Revelations flashbacks)

Altaïr is the philosophical core of Assassin’s Creed. His development from arrogant master to wise mentor establishes the moral framework that defines the entire franchise. While the first game limits his emotional range, his expanded story in Revelations gives him depth, vulnerability, and a clear sense of purpose. Altaïr’s presence echoes throughout Assassin history, and he remains one of the most influential and respected figures in the lore.


Basim Ibn Ishaq (Mirage)

Basim is one of the most intriguing protagonists in the series because he balances human vulnerability with a mysterious and complex inner life rooted in Assassin’s Creed’s deeper lore. Mirage explores his rise from a street thief to a skilled Hidden One, while slowly revealing the forces shaping his destiny. His calm intensity and introspective nature make him compelling even in quieter scenes. Basim stands out because he connects classic AC stealth with modern narrative depth, giving him a unique place in the franchise.

B Tier

Shay Patrick Cormac (Rogue)

Shay is a compelling antihero whose shift from Assassin to Templar is handled with more nuance than many players expected. His motivations are believable, his conflict is layered, and his disillusionment with the Brotherhood creates an emotional arc rarely explored in the franchise. Rogue’s relatively short length limits the full impact of his transformation, but Shay remains one of the most interesting deviations from the typical Assassin’s Creed protagonist path.


Arno Dorian (Unity)

Arno is charming, witty, and relatable, with a personality shaped by loss, romance, and a desire to correct the mistakes of his past. His relationship with Elise gives his story emotional depth, and his self doubtful humor helps him stand apart from more stoic leads. Unity’s troubled launch overshadowed his character, but Arno himself is solid and carries a strong emotional core throughout the narrative.


Aveline de Grandpré (Liberation)

Aveline is sharp, clever, and given a perspective rarely explored in Assassin’s Creed. Her background, relationships, and role in New Orleans make her compelling, and she carries the game with confidence even when the writing or pacing stumbles. Liberation’s smaller platform and experimental mechanics limit her exposure, but Aveline deserves more recognition than she gets.


Naoe (Shadows)

Naoe brings stealth, discipline, and emotional weight to Shadows. Her shinobi background connects directly to the classic Assassin’s Creed identity, giving the story grounded intensity and cultural depth. She is perceptive, driven, and shaped by loyalty and loss, and her missions showcase a patient, skilled fighter who contrasts nicely with Yasuke’s strength focused gameplay. Naoe is compelling, but the dual protagonist structure prevents her from reaching the depth achieved by top tier characters.


Yasuke (Shadows)

Yasuke brings dignity, strength, and presence to Shadows. As a historical figure integrated into Assassin’s Creed, he offers a perspective unlike any other protagonist in the franchise. His story is shaped by his role as an outsider finding purpose in a new land, and his grounded personality contrasts well with Naoe’s intensity. Yasuke is memorable and well performed, but like Naoe, the shared spotlight limits his ability to carry the narrative fully on his own.

C Tier

Jacob and Evie Frye (Syndicate)

Jacob and Evie have great chemistry and distinct personalities. Jacob is reckless and charming, while Evie is thoughtful and disciplined. Together they bring humor and energy to Syndicate, but their dual character structure prevents either from achieving the same emotional depth as top tier protagonists. They are fun and likable, but not as defining as other heroes.


Alexios (Odyssey, alternate protagonist)

Alexios works as a classic heroic figure, but his performance lacks the nuance and presence that make Kassandra iconic. As a result, he feels flatter and less memorable. He is not a bad protagonist, but he is overshadowed by his own counterpart in almost every category.


Lydia Frye (Syndicate, WWI segment)

Lydia has charisma and potential, but her role is brief and serves more as a narrative experiment than a fully fleshed out character journey. She is interesting but far too short lived to have meaningful impact on the franchise.

D Tier

Shao Jun (Chronicles: China portrayal)

Shao Jun is an incredible character in novels and animation, but her Chronicles portrayal does not give her enough narrative space to show her personality or emotional depth. The gameplay focused structure limits her development, making her feel underwritten compared to her importance in Assassin lore.


Arbaaz Mir (Chronicles: India)

Arbaaz is likable and witty, but the small scale of Chronicles prevents him from reaching his potential. His story has interesting elements, but the game’s design gives him little time to develop beyond surface level traits.


Nikolai Orelov (Chronicles: Russia)

Nikolai has an intriguing background tied to late Empire Russia, but like the other Chronicles protagonists, he never receives the character exploration he deserves. His portrayal is brief and thin, limiting his impact.

F Tier

Mobile and Non Canon Protagonists

These characters serve mechanical or experimental roles rather than narrative ones, and they are given so little development that they leave almost no impression. They exist within the franchise, but they play no meaningful role in its identity.

Final Thoughts

Assassin’s Creed has one of the most diverse and interesting casts of protagonists in gaming. Some characters define entire eras. Some elevate their games with strong personality and emotional depth. Others have potential that is limited by short entries or experimental formats.

  • Ezio, Bayek, and Kassandra remain unmatched at the top.
  • Basim, Connor, Edward, and Eivor show the strength of the franchise’s core identity.
  • Naoe and Yasuke add fresh dimension and style to the modern era.
Delayed Respawnse

Some of the links on this site are Amazon affiliate links, which means if you click through and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission—at no extra cost to you. It’s a simple way to help support the site and keep the game recommendations coming. Thanks for your support!

Copyright © 2025 Delayed Respawnse. All Rights Reserved.

Platforms

  • Xbox
  • Playstation
  • Nintendo
  • PC

About

  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Sitemap

Find Your Next Game

  • Take Our Quiz
  • Quiz Results
  • How We Score Games